'The Government Can't Intrude in Worship': John MacArthur Defends Church Reopening to Tucker Carlson
Read Transcript
- In California, COVID-19 restrictions
have prompted the governorto order churches to cease
in person assembly indefinitely.
Grace Community Churchbased in Los Angeles says
they have been the target
of unconstitutionalreligious discrimination
and are continuing to hold services
citing their religious freedom protections
of the United States andCalifornia Constitutions.
And joining us now with more
is one of the attorneysrepresenting the church,
Jenna Ellis.
Jenna tell us a little bit more about
what's going on specifically in this case.
Break it down for us.
- Yeah. Well, the first thingthat you need to know Mark
is that it's not thechurch that's defining
the constitution, it'sthe State of California
and the health officials there.
So the constitutions ofboth the United States
and the State of Californiaprotect the right
of free exercise of religion
as well as freedom of assembling.
And so for the State of California
and any of theirofficials to tell a church
that you cannot perform what is integral
to exercising your faith interms of gathering together,
singing and holding yourservices indefinitely
is not only unreasonableand inappropriate,
but it's not a compelling interest
and it's certainly unconstitutional.
There is no law in Californiathat would allow this
and it's absolutely unconstitutional.
So the church here is simply standing firm
saying we will be open,we are free to exercise
our sincerely held religious beliefs
that are fundamentalrights that are protected
and preserved by the constitution.
That by the way,
the State of California is obligated
to protect and preserve forthe church and instead of that,
they're targeting and persecuting,
harassing and discriminatingagainst the church.
- The order for churchesto halt in person services
it is statewide as you know.
Our other churches like Grace Community
are also standing up against it.
- They are and thereare a few other churches
in the State of Californiathat I have received similar
cease and desist notifications.
In fact, just this morning,
I learned that there's another church
in the California area that'sgotten a specific notice
and that's what pastor John MacArthur
is hoping to do through the statement
that's provided that you can
look at gracecommunitychurch.org.
Which is a statement thatwas unanimously ratified
by his entire elder board.
That's encouraging pastorsto simply stand firm
for the truth.
This church has beenstanding firm on the truth
of the word of God for the past 63 years
and the New Testament Church of Christ
for the past 2000 plusyears as the Church of God.
And so what he is hopingto encourage others through
his stands is thatpastors across the nation
would simply stand firmon truth and stand up
for our sincerely protectedreligious beliefs.
- And overall Jenna,
what are you hoping is theoutcome here from this case?
- Well, I would hope that California
and all of the governorsacross the country recognize
that church is essential
and that we need to be ableto have our church services.
And what no one is talking about Mark
is that there is actualharm that's being occurring
to not only parishioners,but to the church congregants
and to the communities byforcing these church closures.
And that harm isn't just anunconstitutional infringement,
but it's actually a community health harm.
And so what I'm hoping isthat through the awareness
of what the servicesthat are being offered
by the church and recognizing what
an unconstitutional infringement this is,
that the State ofCalifornia will recognize
that this is wrong and thatthey will simply back off
and allow the churcheswithout a fight to continue.
- And quickly, we've onlygot about a minute left,
but this has been an issue since
the beginning of COVID closures.
Why are we still seeingstates pick and choose
what to restrict?
- That's what's remarkable about this
is because you've seenthat governors and states
think that they're the arbiters of
what is and is not anessential business or service
or church.
And they don't have that authority now.
In the very beginning churches,
even like pastorMacArthur's were willing to
for a very brief and limited time,
close their doors and comply with orders.
We want to be good citizens,but as this pandemic continues,
it's unreasonable andit's frankly unwarranted
to say that a church wouldneed to close its doors
for up to a year, like someare already volunteering.
So for the government to thinkthat it can be the arbiter
of what is and is not an essential service
is unconstitutionaland we would stand firm
on the truth that church as essential.
- All right.
Constitutional law attorney, Jenna Ellis.
Thank you Jenna, for your time today.
- Thank you.