Andy and Kate were devastated to learn their daughter had been shot. They knew she was in a better place, and faced with her killer, realized they only had one option.
Read Transcript
The doorbell rang.
And we were shocked to
find a deputy Sheriff
on the other side of the
door, with a woman who
identified herself as
a victim's advocate
with the Leon County
Sheriff's Office.
She was the one who told
us that Ann had been shot.
NARRATOR: Kate
and Andy Grosmaire
had just returned home from
a Palm Sunday service, when
they got the news their
19-year-old daughter, Ann, had
suffered a gunshot
wound to the head.
Ann had spent the day with
her longtime boyfriend, Conor.
I asked was Conor with her.
And it was the
deputy Sheriff who
said that Conor had shot her.
I couldn't process why
that would have happened.
I knew it had to have
been an accident.
It wasn't until we
got to the hospital
and the detective told us that
there had been an argument.
NARRATOR: Conor immediately
turned himself in.
For now, the
Grosmaire's could only
focus on Ann, who
was on life support.
Her father, Andy, stayed
right at her bedside
all night, praying.
About 2:00 in the morning,
I was standing over a bed.
And I heard her
say, forgive him.
And she did not say
those actual words.
But I felt like she
was saying it to me.
Because I knew exactly
what she was talking about.
She has asked me
to forgive Conor.
And I said, no I'm not
going to do it, no way.
After about 25 minutes
of saying no to her,
I finally said, I'll try.
But there she never woke up.
NARRATOR: The next day
the deputy told them
what had taken place at
Conor's house on Sunday.
KATE GROSMAIRE: That's
when we found out
that they had been
having a break-up fight.
And Conner had intended to
get his father's shotgun
to kill himself.
But when Ann came back into the
house, they continued to argue.
And he ended up
pulling the trigger
and shooting Ann instead.
NARRATOR: On Thursday,
the trauma surgeon
showed the Grosmaire's a
CAT scan of Ann's brain,
riddled with shotgun pellets.
It was then they
realized she would have
to be taken off life support.
As I was sitting there
gazing down at her,
I saw her transform in the bed.
And what I saw was Christ became
one with her, not separate,
but just as one,
completely together.
I started sobbing.
And it was because I
realized that Christ
was with my daughter.
And I realized that it was not
Ann asking me to forgive Conor.
It was Jesus.
And how could I say no to
Him, who had forgiven me
for all my transgressions?
NARRATOR: While at
the hospital, Kate
discovered Conor had put her
name on his jail visitation
list.
She went to see him
the next morning.
It was Good Friday.
KATE GROSMAIRE: He
immediately started crying
and said he was sorry
for what had happened.
And I gave him the message
that Andy had given me.
And that was that he
loved him and forgave him.
And I said, Conor,
you know I love you.
And I forgive you.
And once I said
those words, I didn't
feel like I needed to
take them back then.
And I've never felt like I've
needed to come back since.
NARRATOR: Kate returned
to the hospital.
Ann was taken off life
support that afternoon.
She died on Good Friday.
And she died in
the 3 o'clock hour,
the same hour that
Jesus died on the cross.
She is in the arms of Jesus.
She is in heaven.
She is at peace.
NARRATOR: Through a
voluntary legal process
called restorative
justice, the Grosmaire's
were able to sit in
a room with Conor,
while they shared their grief.
And he expressed his
remorse for shooting Ann.
After that meeting, in which
kind of revealed details
of the two day argument
that preceded Ann's death,
they were able to take the first
steps toward reconciliation.
Forgiveness is my part.
Repenting is on the
part of the offender.
And if you don't have
those two pieces,
then you don't have
reconciliation.
NARRATOR: Conor was sentenced
to 20 years in prison.
Andy and Kate visit him
regularly, and call him weekly.
The Grosmaire's
decision to forgive me
was the only reason that I
ever came to believe in God,
and believe in Christ.
There is no other explanation
for the forgiveness
the Grosmaire's showed me.
Normal people do not forgive the
man that kills their daughter.
Normal people would
hate and condemn.
Normal people would be angry,
and hold onto that anger,
and wish me nothing but evil,
and probably want me killed.
Instead, the Grosmaire's decided
to respond with forgiveness,
and respond in love.
And that's nothing but the love
of God shining through them.
NARRATOR: In the years
since Ann's death in 2010,
Kate and Andy have become a
spiritual mother and father
to the young man who took their
daughter's life, nurturing
his newfound faith, and
even attending his baptism,
all because they
were able to forgive.
The main thing
forgiveness has done
for me is to keep me from
going to prison with Conor,
being locked in the cell of
my own hatred, and anger,
and bitterness.
One thing that
Kate said is that she
wants me to live a life
that's worth two lives,
live a life that not makes
up for the life I took,
but at least puts good
back into the world.
I've got to give back.
I've got to serve others.
I've got to help others.
I cannot define Conor
by that one moment.
Because if I defined
Conor by that one moment,
then I was defining Ann
by that moment as well.
And that would make
her a murder victim.
And she was so much
more than that.
So every year,
even though there's
a date that is the
anniversary of her death,
Holy Week will always hold
that special message for us,
that, even though there is
the death on the cross on Good
Friday, Resurrection will
follow on Easter Sunday.