Pastor Caleb Kaltenbach, raised by gay parents, shares how to learn to love others without sacrificing your convictions.
Read Transcript
Well, Caleb has a
very unique story.
Caleb Kaltenbach is with us now.
Welcome.
Hey, thanks having me.
Good to have you here.
What was it like for you to
be raised in the community?
LGBT community?
You know, it was definitely
a very interesting experience.
It was a very fun community,
at least the people
that my mom spent time with.
But it was also a very
passionate community.
My mom joined the board
of directors for Glad
in the local Kansas City
area, she and her partner.
And as a young
elementary age student,
they took me with them
to gay bars, and parties,
and pride parades, and
camp outs, and events.
And as many people have heard,
I marched in these parades.
And I even remember people
spraying urine on people
and holding up signs.
And I remember walking into
a hospital room one time
and watching one of my friends
die from AIDS, who was an older
man-- one of my mom's friends--
and seeing his Christian family
shun him and not
talk to us or them.
And really, my mother
just drilled in my head,
hey, if you're a Christian,
you don't like people
who are different from you.
And so, for me, I grew up,
I couldn't stand Christians.
So how did you, this kid
who didn't like Christians
because you felt they didn't
like the gay community,
how did you find
Christ in your life?
Well, I got invited when
I was in high school--
about 16 years old--
to this Bible study,
led by a high schooler
for high schoolers.
And so I thought I'd
be a ninja Christian.
I'd pretend to be a
Christian and really I'd
learn about Christianity
and dismantle their faith.
And so I went, and I remember
I grabbed this old Bible
off the shelf because
I'd never own one,
and I walked into the
house, and I'd never been
in a Christian house before.
And the first thing
I noticed was,
why do these people
have pictures of sheep,
and lions, and Bible verses
all over their hallway?
And I looked to
my friend, I said,
is that part of the deal
when I turn Christian,
do I have to get a sheep
picture or something like that?
And I went down to
this Bible study
and they were all reading
out of 1 Corinthians,
and I was in 1 Chronicles.
And I learned real quick there
was an Old and New Testament.
But I learned that, actually,
the Jesus of the Gospels,
he was not like the people
in the street corners
or the people in the hospital,
alienating their kids,
that Jesus was different.
He started to
convict my worldview,
and I didn't end up
changing anybody else's.
That Jesus had very deep
theological convictions,
but he also had very
deep relationships
with people who are
not like him, people
who are far from God.
So you become a
Christ follower,
and then you have
this time where
you need to tell your parents
about the change in your life.
How did that go?
Over like a lead balloon,
that's how it went.
I remember-- here's the
best way to describe it.
If you can imagine how
a same-sex attracted
or gay teenager feels
when they come out
to their Christian
parents, I was
a 16-year-old Christian
teenager coming out
to my three gay parents.
And they disown me.
The same treatment
that some people
say that they get from
their Christian parents,
I got from my LGBT
parents because they
feared this extremism,
and they cast
that fear right back on to me.
That's how they reacted.
Your book's really
interesting as you break down
a lot of the reasons
why the gay community
and the Christian community
seem to butt heads,
and the fears involved for both.
So, for someone
who's a Christian,
and if someone comes out
to them and expresses,
hey, I'm homosexual,
give some perspective
on a good way for that
Christ follower to respond.
I would say a few things.
Number one, don't
look disappointed.
I know that we can't always
control our reactions,
but it's a very personal moment.
It's a moment where, even though
we do not agree with the choice
to be in a same-sex
relationship,
or we may not understand
what they mean when they say
that they're same-sex attracted,
they still care enough about us
to tell us, to let us into that
personal part of their life.
So we need to honor that
and not look disappointed.
Don't get mad, don't try
to get them counseling.
Everybody needs counseling,
but that's not the time.
It's not the time to throw
out Bible verses because I'm
willing to bet that
the person telling you
knows you well enough
to know what you
think the Bible says about it.
And the last thing I would
say is, don't compare sins.
Don't compare them to
a murderer, or a thief.
Don't say well that's
like any other sin
because in their mind,
you're comparing them
to Hannibal Lecter
and Gordon Gekko,
and they don't see
that same comparison.
So in this very
vulnerable moment,
OK, some Christians
may respond and say,
well you need to
just stop being gay.
What is a homosexual really
hearing in that statement?
Somebody who hears a Christian
say something like that,
the person who is
same-sex attracted
or identifies as LGBT community,
they see it as an identity.
So what they hear the Christian
say is, give up who you are.
Because a lot of the
times in Christianity
we think that somebody
identifies as LGBT
because of who they want to
be sexually intimate with.
But I remember my
mother and her partner,
my mom told me
one time that they
didn't have sexual intimacy
the last several years
of their relationship.
And I asked my mom, I said, so
you weren't a lesbian anymore?
And she said, well sure I was.
Those are my people, my
community, my relationships.
That's the movement, the
cause I'm involved in.
And it really dawned on
me that for her, it wasn't
about the sexual intimacy.
It was about belonging.
It was about a safe place,
it was about relationships.
And so I think we need to
understand that, yes, we
do need to have
difficult conversations
about sexual intimacy and
other standards of holy living,
but that's not where we start.
Because we don't want
to reduce somebody
down to their sexual orientation
if we're telling people
not to define themselves by
their sexual orientation.
And so, for Christians
who want to be supportive
perhaps, or loving,
how do they navigate
the fact that at
the same time they
may not want to be an
advocate for this lifestyle?
We need to understand
that there's
a big difference between
acceptance and approval.
That we should accept
everybody, no matter what.
And that means you love them
where they're at in their life.
That doesn't mean we approve
of every life choice.
Every weekend I shake hands
with people in my church,
I'm sure I don't approve
of every life choice.
But you know what?
My acceptance for them is
based on my love for God,
and I love them
where they're at.
Tell us about the
interesting change that
occurred in your parents life.
So, my mother's partner
died after 22 years,
and she died without Christ.
My mom went through
a deep depression
because they'd been
together 22 years, right?
And so my family and I
moved to Dallas, Texas
for 3 and 1/2 years,
after pastoring
in Southern California, so that
I could go preach at a church.
We left the summer of 2013 to
go pastor Discovery Church,
where I'm at now,
in Simi Valley.
But when we were in Dallas,
both my parents, separate of one
another, moved there to
be closer to our family.
And then they started
attending my church.
These people who were
the card carrying members
of the ACLU, who my mom was
on the board of directors
for Glad, they were
both professors
that argued against
the rationalization
of Christianity.
They started
attending my church.
And two weeks before we left to
go to California, both of them
submitted their lives to Christ.
And it's incredible.
I have no idea how all
that goes together.
It was just an
incredible thing to see.
And Caleb, why is your
book called "Messy Grace"?
Interesting title.
It's not because
God's grace is messy.
Some people think that.
It's because our
lives are messy.
We're all messy people.
You and me.
First two letters of messy are
the letters, M-E. Me, right?
But God's grace seems messy
when it intersects our lives.
And yet, just like God
had compassion on Nineveh
in the book of Jonah, right--
Jonas told God, he said,
I knew that you would be
quick to compassion and mercy
and grace.
And I think nothing's changed.
I think God looks for
opportunities to be gracious.
Interesting story, Caleb,
and it's a great book.
I really want to encourage you
to get it because Caleb doesn't
instruct or tell us how to
respond to various communities,
but he really gives us
some wonderful perspective
and things to consider
we may not have before.
So if you'd like to pick it
up, it's called "Messy Grace".
It's available wherever
books are sold.
Caleb, thanks again
for being with us.
Thanks for having me.
We really appreciate it.