Christian Student Group Says Univ. of Iowa 'Targeted Leaders' Before Booting Group Off Campus
Read Transcript
- A Christian student groupat The University of Iowa
is asking a federal appeals court
to hold the school accountablefor religious discrimination.
The Business Leaders in Christ
says school officialskicked them off campus
and put it on a religious watch list
for requiring its leaders tosign a statement of faith.
Well joining us now from Becket,
the firm representing the student group,
is senior counsel Eric Baxter.
Eric, welcome to "Newswatch."
- Thank you. Good to be with you.
- Well thanks for joining us.
Tell us more.
Do you think the university singled out
business leaders that believe in Christ?
- Absolutely.
The university asked our clients
to detail their beliefsin their constitution
and then once our clients did that,
the university accusedthem of being bigots
and discriminating becauseof their traditional beliefs
on marriage and sexuality.
And the university thenderegistered our client,
essentially kicking them off campus.
- Where do other religiousgroups on campus stand?
I'm assuming there are otherreligious groups on campus.
Are they able to continue meeting?
- Well after we complained,the university doubled down
and kicked a number of otherreligious groups off campus
for requiring their leadersto share their beliefs,
which you'd think wouldbe pretty common sense.
Ironically, the one group that had beliefs
exactly opposite of our clients
were allowed to remain on campus
and given preferential treatment.
So that was textbook discrimination
in violation of our clients'First Amendment rights.
- That's incredible.
I mean, given that a university
is supposed to be a place where everyone,
free thought is supposed to be celebrated
and different ideas and ideologies,
but not the case it seems.
Well we've seen cases likethis before, of course.
What are you expecting as an outcome?
- Well we've asked the court in this case
to hold the college officials responsible
for what they've done.
We think that no college officialcould believe it was okay
to kick a religious group off campus
unless it changed its beliefs.
It's outrageous that they were even asked
to change their statement of faith.
And so we've asked the court of appeals
to hold those officials accountable
and we're hopeful that thecourt will issue a ruling
in the next three tofour months doing that.
- Eric, what can be done at a higher level
to make sure colleges anduniversities like this one in Iowa
cannot discriminate like this?
- You know, we're reallyproud of our clients,
students who really justwanted to provide a space
for other students tolive out their faith,
but they were willing to take a stand
and stand up for what was right,
to go to the university anddemand that they be treated,
given the same treatment asevery other group on campus.
And I think that's reallyimportant for other students
to see that and be willing tostand up for what they know
are their rights under the Constitution.
- You mentioned that a group
with just the exact oppositebeliefs as this group,
which was a BusinessLeaders in Christ group,
is allowed to remain oncampus and continue to meet.
I'm assuming this is somesort of atheist group?
I don't know if you'reallowed to mention it, but...
- Yeah, no, it was actually the student
who initially complainedabout BLINC's beliefs
about marriage and sexualityformed his own group
and required its leaders
to sign a gay affirmingstatement of faith.
And the university said,
"Well, basically welike what they're doing
"and so we're going to allowthem to stay on campus,
"but we think that what you're doing,"
to my clients, "is bigoted."
And kicked them off campus.
And actually in its briefingscalled our clients out,
saying they just wanted to participate
in illegal discrimination.
A really difficultsituation for our clients
who are really just trying to stand up
for their basic beliefs that are shared
by many, many Americans
and that the Supreme Court has recognized
as decent and honorable beliefs.
- Yeah.
Well it sounds like youhave a very good case
and we wish you all the best
and hope you'll come backand let us know how it goes.