New Netflix Reboot of 'The Baby-Sitters Club' Features 9-Year-Old Transgender Character
Read Transcript
- Welcome back, folks.
You're watching the CBN News Channel.
A new Netflix reboot of the novel series
"The Baby Sitters Club"is drawing attention
for featuring a nine-year-oldtransgender character.
"The Baby Sitters Club" isbased on the popular collection
of G-rated Scholastic books.
The series centers arounda group of adolescent girls
who start a baby sitting business.
In the fourth episode of Netflix's remake,
one of the five baby sitters, Mary Anne,
is asked to care for a child named Bailey
who is presented as a girl,but was biologically male.
The character is played byten-year-old transgender,
Kai Shappley, fromTexas who was born male.
Shappley's story drew attention in 2016
when the then five-year-old's parents
insisted that their child wasactually a transgender girl
and should be allowedto use girl's bathrooms.
Joining us now is Directorof pluggedin.com, Adam Holz.
Adam, great to have youback on the broadcast.
What can you tell us about the difference
between the Netflix show andthe original book series?
- Well, the original book series
was published between 1986 and 2000.
There were 213 novels and itdealt with some tough issues.
It dealt with loneliness;it dealt with divorce;
it dealt with some of the things
that kids were dealing with at the time.
But what we have withthis reboot is, I think,
a reflection of a very progressive agenda
in terms of the way it'streating social issues
like the ones you talkedabout at the outset, George.
- Many have said the show perhaps
is too mature for the age ofthe audience it's targeted at.
What are your thoughts on that?
- You know, I would agree with that.
I have a nine and 11-year-old daughter,
and my nine-year-old found out about it
and asked me "Can I watch?"
And I said, "Well, honey,
I don't think we're quite ready for it."
It is rated "G," butyou need to understand
that TV networks give their own ratings.
And so there are lots ofthings that turn up here
that leave me just sortof scratching my head,
from references to showsthat are way beyond
what kids should be watching,
to one middle school girl says
that she's taking a college art class
and is drawing nudes,
and what it gives is avibe of middle-school girls
who are wise beyond their years.
And as the show progresses wesee them dealing with issues
such as racism, immigration,of climate change.
And the characters hereare really likable.
I really like these girls,
and I like the fact that theshow emphasizes friendship,
it emphasizes trust.
There's some good things here,
but I can't help but feeling
that there's a deeply progressive agenda
that gets packed in hereinto these storylines
that nine and 10, 11-year-oldkids are not really in a place
to know what to do with,
and not the least of themis the transgender character
that you talked about, George.
- How can parents help their kids navigate
the increasing exposure to these issues
in media and entertainment?
As you know these are allissues that we deal with
across the board.
It's not like we're livingback in the '70s or the '80s,
we're in a different time period.
How do we still address that to our kids?
- Well, I think the bestway to do it is to discern
when it's right to haveconversations about things,
and that's gonna depend on the maturity
and the age of your kids.
You may have a 10-year-oldthat really is willing and able
to go into that conversation,
but some 10-year-olds maynot be ready to do that.
So I think that there is a time to say,
"No, this isn't quite appropriate,"
and depending on your child'smaturity, watch it with them,
point out where they'redealing with these issues,
and then have a conversation about it.
And what that models is active engagement
that we don't have to beafraid of these things,
that we have a perspective as Christians
that speaks into these things,
and we can be thoughtful about it,
we don't have to be afraid of it,
but I think what youdon't want to do is think,
"Oh, this is a nice little G-rated show
about middle-school baby sitters,"
and turn your kids loose without any sense
of what the issues arethat they're dealing with,
because then they are goingto be exposed to these things
without your guidanceand without your help
in really enabling them tothink wisely and critically
and Biblically about the issues
that this show is dealing with.
- Okay, terrific, we'llhave to leave it there.
Thank you so much for coming on the show.