650 Cases Out of 3 Million: The NY Times Falsely Accuses Churches as 'Major Source' of COVID-19
Read Transcript
- A new report out in the New York Times
claiming Sunday worship services
are "a major source of COVID-19 cases".
It found 40 churches connected
to around 650 cases of the coronavirus,
but where does that numberstand in comparison?
Joining us to talk about this
and how churches are handling COVID-19
is Doctor Ed Stetzer.
He is the Billy Graham Chair of Church
Mission and Evangelism at Wheaton College.
Doctor Stetzer, as always great
to have you back on the broadcast.
Sir, what do you think of this article
in the New York Times?
Is there error in their claims?
- Well, I don't know.
I mean they claim 650.
I think the challenge is, to use the term
that that's a major cause ora major spread of COVID-19
when we have three million cases.
They talked about 40 churches, 650 cases
since the beginning of the pandemic.
Let me say, I'm onewho's been super cautious
about churches regathering.
I've got resources andwritten on the subject widely.
I'm not in a rush.
My church isn't meeting,
but to say churches are a major spread
when 650 cases out of three million,
that's kind of not the languageI'd use in the headline.
- During this pandemic, as you know,
there's been a lot of outcryfrom Christian leaders
about social distancing restrictions
discriminating against churches
as many governors didn'tallow services to take place,
but kept other essential businesses open.
Is this NYT article just another example
of bias or targeting of churches?
- Well, when I wrote anarticle and I responded to it
in Christianity Today is that
this was a headline in search of a story.
The story actually tellsthat a third of the cases
related to churches werefrom one church in Oregon
that didn't follow protocols.
And what I would sayis, there's good quotes,
there's good information in the story.
The framing of it is the problem.
Churches have been significant partners
working with governments, local, county,
and state health departments,and are not culprits here.
They're partners here.
And I found the framingof the article unhelpful.
Is it a result of bias?
I don't know.
You know, editors pick headlinesrather than the reporters.
What I would say is it framed the story
in a way that was unhelpfuland I think untrue.
Here's another way you could frame it:
only 650 cases traced to churches
among three million people with have been
diagnosed with COVID-19in the United States.
Churches are doing well,they're being cautious.
Pastors love their people justlike health departments do
and they're making wisechoices, by and large.
- Yeah, real quickly last few seconds,
what would you advice be to churches
who are open and those who are attending?
- I would say follow socialdistancing protocols,
follow cleaning protocols.
There's lots of resourcesonline now how to do that.
Make wise choices as you regather.
- Yeah okay, terrific.
Thank you so much asalways Doctor Stetzer.
Thank you for coming.