'How Many Children Are Going to Be Harmed?' The Medical Risks of Treating Children with Gender Dysphoria
Read Transcript
- [Heather] Transgenderhealthcare for kids
is a fast-growing medical specialty.
In the US, dozens of clinicspromote a single approach
known as gender affirmative treatment.
- It's just amazing how quickly
this phenomenon has kind of arisen,
and then how extensive it is.
It went from nothing to 45,
and they're at the mostelite institutions.
- [Heather] And it's catchingmany parents off guard.
- She came into the kitchen one night
when I was cooking dinner
and just told me, "Mom, I'mtransgender, I'm a boy."
- [Heather] The USProfessional Association
for Transgender Health
wrote the US Surgeon General last year,
claiming consensus amongproviders over the treatment.
But a small group of pediatricians
who specialize in hormones
are raising serious concerns.
Dr. Paul Hruz is one of them.
- We really have no longterm data
in using this intervention in children.
What we do have are short-term studies
that have very seriousweaknesses and limitations.
- [Heather] Hruz is a pediatric researcher
at the Washington UniversitySchool of Medicine
who is worried about thelongterm health of kids
who receive gender affirmative treatment.
The first step known as social affirmation
can begin as early as three years old.
- So rather than questioning somebody
who asserts a gender identity
that's not in agreement with their sex,
that one actuallysupports that individual.
- That support can include
allowing children to cross-dress,
use new pronouns,
and enter opposite-sex bathrooms.
The next step, puberty blockers,
can start as early as eight.
Advocates say they buy time for children
to think through changing their gender
and help to prevent suicide
related to distress around gender.
Dr. Hruz says that while statistics show
this might work in the short term,
there's no evidence theseblockers curb suicidal thoughts
in the long term.
- What's most concerning
is that if you look atwhat data is available
in these children that are given
this gender affirming approach,
that the suicidal ideationremains markedly elevated.
- [Heather] And he questions
whether preventing a keydevelopmental stage like puberty
is good science.
- Maybe the parallel is
if a child has a math exam next week
and you tell them thatthey don't need to take it,
that's gonna relieve theiranxiety about the test,
but have you really helped that child?
- [Heather] If a child persists
in questioning their gender identity,
this gender affirmative treatment
calls for prescribing cross-sex hormones
and even surgery when children reach 18.
But studies like thisone show that, in fact,
surgeons are performingdouble mastectomies
on teenage girls.
The combined whammy of puberty blockers
plus cross-sex hormones
can take a huge hit on adolescent bodies,
starting with infertility.
- It's expected that the outcome is
to result in lifelong sterility,
so you're taking away a child's fertility
at an age when they reallydon't have an understanding
of what they're giving up.
- [Heather] There'salso research that shows
increased risk of strokeand metabolic changes
that can lead to heart attacks,
diabetes and weakened bones.
- Puberty is a very important time
for acquiring bone density,
and that if that is interrupted,
the children are gonna beat risk of osteoporosis
and fractures later in life.
And the question thatneeds to be asked is,
if this turns out notto be a good approach,
how many children are going to be harmed?
- Unbelievably, thesemedical interventions
could be totally unnecessary.
Even the World Professional Association
of Transgender Healthcare
acknowledges research showing
that most children with gender issues
will outgrow it before adolescence.
Just last month,
the United Kingdom'sNational Health Service
quietly changed its guidanceon these interventions.
"Little is known aboutthe long-term side effects
"of hormone or pubertyblockers in children.
"It is not known what thepsychological effects may be.
"It's also not knownwhether hormone blockers
"affect the developmentof the teenage brain
"or children's bones."
The action may have beenfueled by the protests
at a London transgender clinic.
As The Telegraph reports,
35 staff have resignedin the last three years,
concerned about over-diagnosisof gender dysphoria in kids.
Dr. Hruz acknowledges the tough road
that parents of childrenstruggling with their gender face.
He encourages them to support their kids
and be cautious aboutthe affirmative approach.
They can also consider counseling
to understand psychologicalfactors that may be present,
or a wait-and-see approach,
knowing that their childmay outgrow their distress.
- Parents often understand,
they're looking at the bestinterest of their children,
they know their children,they love their children,
and they don't wanna doanything to harm their children.
Parents being educatedabout what is really known
and what is not known about this condition
and what the alternatives are
I think can help them inmaking those decisions.
- [Heather] Decisions thatcan influence their child
for a lifetime.
Heather Sells, CBN News.