Federal Judge Tells Cuomo and de Blasio to Stop Discriminating Against Churches: 'Absolute Monarchy'
Read Transcript
- And here with us nowis Christopher Ferrara,
a Thomas More Society lawyer working
to allow churches to reopen.
Christopher, thanks for beingwith us on Faith Nation today.
The judge here in thiscase is Gary Sharpe.
I take it he was pretty critical
of Governor Cuomo and Mayor de Blasio.
- Well, I think the court had to be
because the position wasessentially indefensible.
There was a vast networkof regulations governing
capacity limitations of variousbusinesses and entities.
And I look at it as akind of inverted pyramid.
At the very bottom of the inverted pyramid
all alone in the 25%indoor occupancy limitation
was religion, just religion, nothing else.
Now on the eve of the judge's ruling,
I understand that the governorhas leapfroged religion
into phase four throughout the state,
but even in phase four,religion and religion only
is at 33% indoor occupancy.
Whereas the judge's ruling issued today
says essentially this,that religious gatherings,
like other businessgatherings are entitled
to a 50% occupancy limitation.
There's no rational basisto distinguish, for example,
restaurants at 50% capacity
from a house of worship at 50% capacity.
So he held that the regulationof capacity limitations
was not generally applicable.
He reserved the question asto whether it was neutral
on its face, but found that it definitely
was not being applied ina generally applicable way
and that religion had been singled out
as an especially strictgathering limitation indoors.
And as to the outdoor gatherings,
he said that these areessentially gone now
with the massive exception allowed
for protests of unlimited numbers.
So he held that outdoor gatherings
cannot be limited as to our clients.
They need only practice thesocial distancing guidelines
for outdoor gatherings,
but there's no longer astrict numerical limitation
to 25 people in the NorthCountry, for example,
or 10 people, which was applicable
in the lower half of the state,especially in New York City.
That's gone now because theyhave a effectively abolished
that whole framework by allowing
these massive demonstrations,
and they should allow demonstrations.
They're First Amendmentprotected activity.
It's not even just the demonstrations.
It's also celebrations ofJuneteenth, for example,
thousands were demonstratingand celebrating
for the Juneteenth celebrationon the 19th of June.
Essentially New York is nowjust filled with gatherings
and celebrations of all kinds.
So that outdoor gathering limitation
is essentially history at this point.
- Just a few seconds left here, but what's
the immediate effect ofthis judge's ruling today?
- Well, the immediate effectas to these plaintiffs
is that they're relieved
of these indoor restrictions at 25%.
The restriction should be 50%as with comparable businesses
and they're relieved of anyoutdoor gathering limitations.
There is no outdoor gatheringlimitation any longer.
They need only practice social distancing.
- Out of time, we're gonna have to go.
I'm so sorry.- That's okay.
- Thanks for being with us today.
- Thanks, Christopher.
- [John] Coming up, thefastest two minutes in sports,
making up for a delayed start.
That story when we come back.
- It's the new Superbook Bible App.
It's packed with games, activities,
and Superbook episodes thatyou can watch for free.
Oh no!
There's trivia, fun daily devotional,
and answers to your Bible questions,
plus an easy to understand Bible
the whole family will enjoy.
You can even create your ownSuperbook character, ta-da!
It's the new Superbook Bible App.
Free downloads on iTunes,Google Play, and Amazon.
- [Announcer] From WashingtonD.C., uncompromising stories,
interviews, and analysisfrom veteran journalists,
David Brody.- Escalating fight.
- [Announcer] Jenna Browder.
- Chose his words carefully.
- [Announcer] Ben Kennedy.
- Plan to join him.
- [Announcer] And Amber Strong.
- For impeachment growsa little bit louder.
- [Announcer] Bringing you thepolitical news that matters.
- We get out and tellthe story of the progress
that we're making in this country.
- [Announcer] Watch FaithNation, weeknights at 6:00
on the CBN News Channel.
- We will move the Americanembassy to the eternal capital
of the Jewish people, Jerusalem.
- [Announcer] As the nations rage,
you can stand with Israel.
- History is being written,and I wanna be a part of it.
- [Announcer] Call1-800-700-7000 and get "To Life."
- [Woman] This is our nature as a country.
- [Announcer] Discover the untold story
of how Israeli volunteersare changing the world.
- [Man] We consider itour duty to reach out
and help others around the world.
- [Announcer] For a gift of $10 or more,
you can own the acclaimedCBN documentary "To Life."
- To treat a human, no matter what he is,
which religious hehave, which color he is,
this is what I'm doing.
- [Announcer] Support Israelin their time of need.
Get "To Life," now available on DVD.
Call 1-800-700-7000 or log on to cbn.com.
- [Woman] And I wish that otherpeople throughout the world
could see this side of Israel.
- Finally, tonight, goodthings come to those who wait.
Ticket holders for May's Kentucky Derby
will get to go after all, John.
- That's right, the Derbyhas been rescheduled
for September 5th,under strict guidelines.
In light of the pandemic,
the Louisville venueannounced safety procedures,
including limiting crowdcapacity, requiring masks
and reducing credentialsfor media and guests.
- All three of the Triple Crown races.
The Kentucky Derby hasthe distinction of running
uninterrupted for 144 years.
For people living duringthe Great Depression,
you can see these photos hereand during the World Wars,
the race was a joyful and uplifting event.
Hopefully it can be that again, this year,
we all kind of need that, John.
- I will hear hear that.
Well, thanks for joining us.- Yeah, have a great.