'We're Meeting In-Person This Sunday': Churches Fight 'Petty Tyrants' in Reopening Battles from NJ to MA
Read Transcript
- In New Jersey, COVID-19 shutdowns
sparked a federalreligious liberty lawsuit
against Governor Philip Murphy.
The Thomas More Societyhas sued Governor Murphy
on behalf of a Jewishrabbi and a Catholic priest
whose religious rights were violated
with the issuing of selective enforcement
of New Jersey's COVID-19stay-at-home orders.
Attorney Christoper Ferrerajoins us now with more.
Christopher, great to have on the show.
So give us here, realquickly, a little more detail
on what happened that led to this lawsuit
in the first place.
- Well what we have going on in New Jersey
is something that has never been seen
in the history of that state
or in the history of this country.
We have a governor who isliterally micromanaging
the lives of millions of people
with a series of executive orders
that govern when they may leave home,
where they may shop, whatbusinesses may operate,
what businesses may not operate,
and also tightly regulating divine worship
by strictly limiting the number of people
who can be involved inin-person worship services.
It is our position in this suit,
given the developments of recent days,
that the entire rationale forthis regime of restrictions
on millions of people collapsed
when Governor Murphy not onlyendorsed, but participated in,
mass marches in protest ofthe death of George Floyd,
undoubtedly the victimof police brutality.
Now that's a worthy First Amendment cause,
thousands marched for it,
and if thousands can marchfor it shoulder-to-shoulder
with the governor participating,
where is the threat of the virus, we ask.
There is no threat that would warrant
a continuation of this lockdown.
The problem we see now isthat we have a governor
who is adjusting his executive orders
to suit his value judgementsand prefaces of the moment,
or preferences of the moment.
So when he was called out
for having participatedin mass gatherings,
violating the rules that he lays down
for millions of others, heissued an executive order,
executive order 152,that suddenly declares
that everyone now hasFirst Amendment rights
in the state of New Jersey again
as far as outdoor gatherings go,
provided the gatheringsare for the purposes
of political protest or religion.
- Yeah and--- We find that very curious.
- Sure.
Christopher, let me just ask you this.
Where do things stand now
with the easing of these restrictions,
especially as the state enters phase two?
- Well, the way things stand now
is that indoor worshipservices are still restricted,
unfairly and unjustifiably,
to 25% of the capacity of the room
in which the service is conducted,
or 50 persons, whichever is less.
So theoretically, if youhave a very small room,
that would be one personrepresenting 25% of the capacity
or if you have a church that seats 1,000
you can only have 50people in that church.
Meanwhile, of course,businesses of all kinds,
accounting firms, law firms,manufacturing facilities,
favorite retail businesseswith staff in the facilities
have no such restrictions.
We're told now that indoor gatherings
can only occur if theyinvolve this magical number,
this limited number of 50 persons.
But what exactly distinguishesan indoor gathering
from an office gathering of,say, accountants or lawyers?
The scheme that this governor has imposed
on the state of New Jerseymakes less and less sense
as the days go by and we find
that the situation hasbecome simply intolerable.
There's no more justification.
- Mr. Ferrera, I'm going tohave to leave it right there.
We've run out of time.
Thank you so much for coming on the.