Four Theories that Try to Explain Away Christ's Resurrection – and Why They Don't Add Up
Read Transcript
- Christianity's powerall hinges on the fact
of the Resurrection, butdetractors for centuries
have come up with scenarios
to explain away the realityof the Resurrection.
One is the wrong tomb theory.
Everyone just went to thewrong tomb, an empty one,
and assumed Christ had resurrected.
Indiana doctor, Joseph Bergeron,
studied the crucifixion ofChrist and its aftermath
for 10 years.- Going to a wrong tomb
and finding it empty
doesn't present to anybody's mind
that the person resurrected from the dead.
- [Paul] Alex McFarlandis another top defender
of the faith at events like Bible camps
and apologetics conferences.
He points out another well known fact.
- Pilate had dispatcheda cadre of Roman soldiers
to guard the tomb.
- So everybody knew where it was.
- [Paul] There's also the swoon theory.
They want you to believeinstead of dying on the cross,
Jesus only passed out,
woke up in the tomb acouple of days later,
rolled away the huge stone, and escaped.
McFarland says impossible.
- Christ has been atleast two to three days
without food or water, dehydrated,
he was beaten severely,huge loss of blood,
nailed to the cross.
- [Paul] And if the alwaysfatal crucifixion process
hadn't already killed him,
Roman soldiers made sure.
- They plunged a spear into his chest
because to allow any possibility
that he would survive the crucifixion,
would mean that they would die themselves.
- [Paul] McFarland explainsthe swoon theorists
then present this unlikely scenario.
- He revived himself, he moves a 2 1/2
to three-ton stone,
he overcomes a dozen Roman soldiers
in peak physical condition.
- [Paul] McFarland alsosees a moral problem
with what the swoon theoristswant you to believe.
- He told his disciples he had risen
and he allowed them to go forth
and preach what was false,
and die for what really wasn't true.
This compromises the moral
righteous nature of the person Jesus.
- [Paul] The stolen body theory proposes
that the very disciples who fled in terror
after the crucifixion then risked death
to steal Christ's body from the tomb,
and then made up thewhole resurrection story.
- They sufficiently regatherand summon up enough bravery
to overcome Roman soldiers.
I mean, this could havebeen at best arrest,
if not execution and death.
They move the stone, theytake away the body of Jesus,
they say he's risen.
- [Paul] But that wouldhave been the opposite
of Jesus' life and teaching.
- Everything he's all about ispredicated on righteousness,
virtue, truth, holiness.
Here is truth personified,and they build a gospel
on a lie?
It just doesn't make sense.
- [Paul] And all butone of those disciples
was put to death for this gospel.
- People sometimes will diefor some misguided belief
that they have.
Nobody dies for a hoax.
- One popular idea is thateveryone who saw Jesus alive
after his death was just hallucinating.
Bergeron points out, though,
in the rare documented casesof group hallucinations,
they all see different things.
- None of them experiencethe same exact thing.
- [Paul] Because it's all in their mind.
McFarland points out the risen Christ
appeared several times and interacted
with hundreds of people,
as recorded in 1st Corinthians 15.
- Paul says he was seen byup to 500 brethren at once.
- Hallucination hypothesescan never explain
the group appearances,the group experiences
the disciples had with Jesus.
- Hallucinations are not contagious.
Hallucinations generally don'tappear in different places
to different groups of people.
You generally can't talk and converse
with an hallucination.
And you certainly can'teat with an hallucination.
- [Paul] So why not just believe
in what the son of God promised he'd do?
Resurrection.- His identity, message,
credentials were validatedby the fact that he did
what none of us coulddo under our own power.
He rose from the dead.
- I'm more convinced thatwhat we believe as Christians
is true and accuratethan I ever have been.
- Like so many othersacross the millennia,
Bergeron contends the best explanation
for why Jesus wasn't inthat tomb Easter morning,
is what Christ's discipleshave always said.
He came alive and rose from it.
Paul Strand, CBN News,reporting from Indiana.