Movement to 'Push Back': Lawmakers' Bills Target Transgender Medical Interventions, Athletes
Read Transcript
- There's growing momentum in the movement
to push back against transgender activism.
Last night the South Dakota House
passed a bill that would prevent doctors
from treating gender confused children
with hormones and sexreassignment surgery.
It's the first state in the nation
to take action on such an issue.
The ACLU is promisingto fight back in court
if the bill passes.
On the sports front,
female athletes are also pushing back.
They're opposed by transgender activists
who want boys and men that identify
as female to be able tocomplete against them.
At the high school levelthere's growing concern
that young women don't have a chance
when it comes to trans athletes.
In Connecticut, for instance, two boys
identifying as girls hold
15 state championship track titles.
In Washington, seven GOP lawmakers
are sponsoring a bill tolevel the playing field.
Heather Sells joins us now with more.
Heather.
- Yes, Mark, the house bill would deny
Title Nine funding to women's sports
that allow biological males to compete.
It is part of a new movement
that is pushing back againsttransgender activists.
These activists say thatit is discrimination
if sports authorities don't allow
trans athletes to competein their preferred gender.
The debate over transgender rights
is playing out at highschools across the country.
The problem for female athletes
when they have to competeagainst male athletes,
they're out matched.
Connecticut is one of 17 states
that allow this to happenwith no restrictions.
Unlike the NCAA, these athletes
don't even have to take hormonesthat suppress testosterone.
Track athlete Selena Soule
faced this trans athletesher freshman year.
- And once the gun went off
the two transgenderathletes took off flying,
and left all of us girls in the dust.
I knew right then and there
that some girls would be missing out
on great opportunities to succeed.
- [Heather] Soule and Alanna Smith,
both considered elite track talent,
are up against two trans athletes
who have taken 15 Connecticutstate championship titles
from females in just the last two years.
- It's not about thatthey are transgender,
it's about that it's not fair
to everybody else in our category
because we know they have aphysical advantage over us.
And sports is somethingthat should be fair.
- [Heather] Soule andSmith are fighting back
with a title ninediscrimination complaint.
They want the ConnecticutInterscholastic Conference
to revise its rules on trans athletes.
In the meantime,
lawmakers in nine other states
are trying to level the playing field
with bills such as requiring athletes
to compete in the gender
stated on their birth certificate.
Activists like the ACLUcall that discrimination,
saying individuals shouldhave the right to compete
in their preferred gender.
Alliance Defending Freedom attorney
att Sharp argues it's about fairness
for biological females.
- Everyone knows that thereare biological differences
between males and females.
And the whole reason we have laws
like Title Nine thatprotects opportunities
for females was in responseto these realities.
- [Heather] Some conservativecampaign strategists
plan to use the issue in 2020,
calling transgender sportsweak ground for progressives.
- We're looking forwardto using this issue
in really important elections
such as Michigan andGeorgia, North Carolina.
These states are gonna be crucial,
not just to the presidency,
but also to keeping the Senate.
And the voters there are very normal.
They're very fair minded.
And they're gonna bevoting on issues like this.
- It's a potential fight effecting anyone
who cares about thefuture of women's sports.
And, Mark, this issuereally has the ability
to make a dramatic impact on athletes
of all ages and their families.
- Heather, it's interesting because
women's sports really havegrown since Title Nine
was established,
and now the future seems so uncertain.
- Right, Title Nine wasestablished in 1972,
and the Women's Sports Foundation,
which was founded by tennisstart Billie Jean King,
says that there has beenalmost a 1,000% increase
in the number of womenplaying high school sports,
plus a 500% increase at the college level.
But that is all on the line right now.
- Where do you think thislegislation might go?
- Well in Washington there's no movement
in the Senate right now,
and Democrats control the house,
so it's hard to imaginethis bill going anywhere.
But we will be watchingto see where it goes
at the state level,
and if more states take the...