New LGBTQ Rights Bill Offers Religious Liberty Protection–But Is It Enough?
Read Transcript
- The bill known as Fairness For All
expands the Civil Rights Act of 1964
to include sexual orientationand gender identity.
It also provides exemptionsfor religious liberty,
and that's key for people of faith
who have watched theirprotections decline,
while those for LGBTQ people have grown.
In New York, wedding businessowner, Cynthia Gifford,
had to pay state fines after refusing
a same-sex ceremony on her property.
- When the governmenttells you what to say
and punishes you if youdon't, is scary stuff.
- [Heather] Christiancolleges and universities
have also faced a host ofreligious liberty battles,
so they work to frame the bill.
- It's very important in America
to be able to teach and to have policies
that reflect a conservative, orthodox
and historical position on marriage,
and we wanna make sure there's no penalty
around those beliefs in the future.
- [Heather] A small group of gay activists
have also pursued the bill.
They say it's a far betterdeal for people of faith
than the radical Equality Act,
which House Democrats passedunanimously last spring.
- And eventually both of thesesides and both of these bills
are going to have start working together
to find something that can actually pass
both chambers of Congressand be signed by a president.
- [Heather] The bill's Republican sponsor,
Utah Representative, Chris Stewart,
says it's time for lawmakers to resolve
the country's debateover religious liberty.
- I think it's better for us in society
if the courts don't haveto resolve these issues
one at a time, often inconflicting findings,
and over many, many years.
That leads to uncertainly,and in too many cases,
strife and conflict.
- [Heather] But conservativesat the Heritage Foundation
and Alliance Defending Freedom
say the religious libertyprotections are weak
and that elevating sexualorientation and gender identity
to a protected class will harmliberty, privacy and safety.
- There are many of uswho believe that this bill
concedes far, far, far too much
and undermines theinterest of young people
who are suffering from gender dysphoria
or of their parents of women and girls
who wanna compete on an equalplaying field in athletics.
- Those backing FairnessFor All say people of faith
need an alternative to the Equality Act,
which most believe would severely
threaten religious liberty.
They believe Fairness For All could lead
to a longterm discussion and solution
with the LGBTQ community.
Heather Sells, CBN News.