Court Rules University of Iowa Officials Must Pay From Their Own Pockets For Their Religious Discrimination
Read Transcript
- A federal judge has ruledthe University of Iowa
violated the law when it kicked
InterVarsity ChristianFellowship off the campus.
The university expelled the group
along with other religious groups in 2018
for insisting that anyone in leadership
must affirm its Christian beliefs.
The university called therequirement discrimination.
The Becket Fund for ReligiousLiberty defended InterVarsity.
It reported the courtsaid the discrimination
was so bad the officers involved
and possibly even theuniversity's president
would be personallyaccountable for any money
InterVarsity lost fightingto stay on campus.
Eric Baxter is an attorneywith Becket Law Firm
and he joins us now.
Eric, tell us briefly a little more
about the background of this case.
What happened initially?
- Well, initially theuniversity, you know,
InterVarsity's been on itscampus for over 25 years.
It's been an award-winning part of campus
recognized for the contributions it makes
to a diverse campus life.
A couple of years agothe university decided
that when religious groupsrequire their leaders
to be religious that wassomehow discrimination
in violation of the university'santi-discrimination policy
and so the university kicked 12 or more
religious groups off campus.
This included Sikhs,Christian groups, Catholic,
Latter-day Saint, Muslim groups,
kicked all of them off campus
because they require theirleaders to share their faith.
And our client, InterVarsity,brought a lawsuit
noting that this was actuallyreligious discrimination
against groups because of their beliefs.
- This was a big win for InterVarsity.
What can you tell us about how they
and the university areresponding to the ruling?
- Unfortunately, the universityjust continues to dig
itself deeper and deeper.
The judge ruled in another case
where we represented a group
called Business Leaders in Christ
and the court ruled back in January
that it was a violation oftheir First Amendment rights
for the university to pressure them
to give up their leaderswho shared their faith.
The university went ahead
and kicked other groups offcampus including InterVarsity
and so the judge's most recent opinion
said no reasonableperson could have reacted
to that first order byhoming in on religious groups
more broadly and kickingthem off campus too.
And even after this latest ruling
the university has issued a press release
saying well, we were compelledto do what we were doing
by federal law, which is just false.
In fact, the judge warned the university.
She said, "I don't think any of you know
"what the First Amendment means
"and you need to get your act in order
"if you want to avoid liability."
So unfortunately theuniversity doesn't seem
to get the message still
but hopefully the judge's latest order
will eventually sink in.
- What comes next, I meanwhat does InterVarsity
have planned for theirfuture on the campus?
- Well, InterVarsity's thrilled
to have full recognizedstatus back on campus.
They want to continue their ministry.
The hardest part of this whole experience
has been the interferencethat it's created
with their ability toreach out to students
and help them live their faith.
And so InterVarsity's justthrilled to be back on campus.
The judge has setdeadlines for the parties
to consider a trial on the damages
and whether the universitypresident should himself
be personally liable for allowingthis to happen on campus.
- InterVarsity faces a similar case
at Wayne State University, Michigan.
Do you think this rulingwill affect that case
or others going forward?
- Absolutely, I think this ruling
sends a very strong message
that what the universities are doing
when they target religious organizations
because of their faith standards,
that is unconstitutional andthat university officials
will feel it in the pocketbook
if they keep pressuring students
who want to live out their faith
while they go to school.
- All right, thank you, Eric Baxter
of Becket Law Firm, that is.
Thanks so much for yourtime and your insights.
- My pleasure.