Marc Short and A.B. Stoddard Weigh in on Immigration Debate and Gun Control
Read Transcript
- Joining the conversationis A.B. Stoddard
with RealClearPolitics.
A.B., good to have you.
You know, the Trump administration,
they're taking a lot of heatfor this green card crackdown.
- Well, I think that it's not surprising
that the president continues to try to act
by executive order without negotiations
with the Congress on this issue.
It is a big, importantpolicy priority for him
going into reelection, andhe is trying to energize
this sentiment aboutimmigration among his voters.
He has talked for a whileabout merit-based immigration
and how we should be bringing in people
who are ready to do jobs.
There are actually a lot of voters
in the mainstream of the electorate
who don't support Donald Trump
who also support merit-based immigration.
I think that the way thathe continues on this issue
to be divisive with his rhetoric
and to sort of not embrace a sit-down
with the separate and co-equal branch
makes it more of a political liability
in terms of the peoplewho are opposing him
and Democrats out on theprimary campaign trail
talking about his crueltyand his divisiveness.
Where, is this is actuallya proposal that if it,
if it was on the tableamong other provisions
in an immigration package,it might be watered down,
but it might actuallyend up being included.
It's the way that hedrops these policy bombs
by executive action and thensort of prompts a reaction
from Democrats that makesit more controversial
and unpopular than it probably would be
in a different setting.
- Marc, the point youhear people make out there
is that the base of theStatue of Liberty says
give me your poor, give me your tired,
and critics say that Acting Director
of Citizenship andImmigration Ken Cuccinelli
has basically rewritten those words
to say we're looking for those
who stand on their own two feet.
Is this a sign of changing times?
- You know, I think one thingthat would be a surprise
probably to a lot of your viewers
is that this administrationactually naturalized
more citizens last yearthan the 10 year average,
including the eight yearsof the Obama administration.
I think this administration welcomes those
who come to this country to work
and I think that thepresident wants to embrace,
we want to embrace lawful reform.
And you know, one thingI would take issue with
that A.B. laid out as the former head
of Legislative Affairsfor this White House,
I tried to get Democrats,on many occasions,
to partner with us on immigration reform.
But I think it's an issuethat's so politicized today
that there's not an effort
to try to negotiate on these terms.
And so we've pleaded withDemocrats on several occasions
to give us more beds forthe crisis at the border.
We've pleaded with themto give us the tools
we think we need toenforce immigration laws.
And sadly, there isn't the cooperation
that we wish there was on these issues.
- Another issue that has bothsides divided, gun control.
The president made a boldcall for gun control measures
on Friday.
A.B., how does he play thiswith his conservative base?
- Okay, so this is an issue
like what Marc pointed out on immigration.
He had a deal on the table with Democrats,
a DACA deal for border wall funding,
and he walked away from itbecause the amnesty crowd,
people who perceive any kindof legalization of anything,
especially for Dreamers, isamnesty, brought him back.
He was at the table on guncontrol after Parkland.
I thought that he exhibitedvery brave leadership
bringing the Parkland students,
the survivors into the White House,
sitting there on camera wherethey could've screamed at him
and challenged him publicly.
He was all on board forstrong background checks,
all sorts of things.
He even mentioned confiscation
at one televised meeting with Democrats.
But then he walked it all back
and admitted that the NRAhad influenced his positions.
When he has Rush Limbaugh saying
that if he gets to the leftof the NRA and his voters,
he's gonna lose reelection
just like George Herbert Walker Bush did
when he raised taxes.
These are the pressures he'll be under,
and this is why everyone is so skeptical
that he actually willcome around in September
to background checks that he's saying
he's supporting now.- Marc, how does
the administration thread the needle
on such a delicate issue?
- Well I think we,first, should step back.
I think that, one of the things
you heard the vice presidentsay in remarks last week
is that when you drive Godout of the public square
and you drive him out of public schools,
there has been a moraldecay in our country
and I think that is a root of the problem.
And too often, we'remisdiagnosing the problem.
Specific to guns,
I do think that there's probably,actually more opportunity
for compromise on thisissue in the weeks ahead
and I think that you will seelegislation move in September.