'Nobody's Being Forced': CA Pastor Denies Clergy Being Pushed to Affirm LGBT Ideology
Read Transcript
- CBN News recently reportedon a recently passed resolution
in California that forces pastors
to embrace pro-LGBT ideology,
but some pastors in the statesay there's more to the story.
They say the measures goal is
to promote compassiontowards the LGBT community.
Joining us now to talk aboutthat is Pastor Dan Carroll
of Water of Life Church.
Welcome Pastor Carroll.
- Thank you Charlene.
- First of all, explainto us exactly what ACR 99,
this resolution is andit's intended purpose.
- Well first, it's a resolution.
It's not a law.
That's really important to say.
Nobody's being forced to do anything.
It's a suggestion.
And so, a year ago, we had AB 2943.
Many of you are familiar with that
because that was a law andit was a very restrictive
and oppressive law.
It was a law that would've forced us to
withdraw books from our bookstores
that were anything in thosebooks that was not pro-gay,
was not pro-homosexual,
and so one of the discussions that we had
at that time was the Bible.
Are you really telling usthat you're going to try
to outlaw the Bible becausethe Bible's not pro-homosexual
in many places and actuallythere's six verses that deal
with homosexuality at lengththat are not pro-homosexual.
So we had those kinds of discussions
and during the time thatwe had those discussions,
we contacted our local assembly people
and we ended up in adiscussion with Evan Low
who was the author of AB 2943
and he was willing to pull the bill
and use a resolution instead of the bill
and that's what ACR 99 is, is a resolution
that replaced AB 2943, a bill.
And so the resolution waswritten several different times,
probably six or sevendifferent times for us
and then Evan actuallyused his own resolution
as the final and it wasn'tsomething that we all embraced
at any level, but that'skind of the backdrop
of what took place there.
- So let me just besure, for those who are,
you know, arguing that thisis going to force pastors
to restrict them from sayingthat homosexuality is a sin,
so that's not what this resolution is?
- Well, no.
Somebody like Roger Gannon,who Roger and I have spoken
at this from Liberty Council,Roger feels that this
opens a door to communitieshousing legislation
in their local cities thatwould be more restrictive
and there's no doubt that this is not
a completely positive event.
I'm not trying to sell it as that,
what I'm trying to sayis that it's much better
than a law that we haveto go to court and fight.
- And you mentioned that youand several other pastors
have been working behind the scenes
with Assemblyman Evan Low,the author of the resolution.
And due to your relationship,you're saying that
the legislation in ACR 99 is a lot easier
or more favorable towardpastors in the state.
Tell us a little bit more about that.
- Well, because of therestrictiveness of AB 2943,
it was so oppressive that we contacted
our local Assemblywoman,her name is Eloise Reyes,
and went over and metwith her in her office
and she, we had a granddiscussion with her
and she was so taken by our time
that she offered me anappointment with Evan Low
if I would fly to Sacremento.
And I, unbeknownst to me, I had no idea
that a lot of pastors weretrying to get in touch with Evan
at that time because I'mreally not one of the pastors
who would typically participatein the political arena.
But in this particular case, it was so,
it was just a very discouragingand oppressive bill
and so I got involved in it at that level.
I ended up flying toSacremento, met with Evan,
and shared my heart with him.
He was very thoughtful, very receptive,
and listened very intently.
he was quite honoringactually and I tried to do
the same thing with him and care for him
as a human being, asa person, love on him.
And he asked me at thatpoint if I would be willing
to work with him on the lawand allow him to come down
to meet with pastors at my church.
So Evan flew to our churchin Fontana, California
and met with probably 30pastors that I selected
and asked to come infor a meeting with Evan
that we could have aninteractive discussion.
That lasted probably twohours and it was really
a profitable discussion to the point that
Evan actually told us that hewas willing to pull the bill,
thought it had beenpassed by the whole Senate
and the Assembly and it was sitting,
waiting for a Governor's signature.
And to his credit, he did do that.
He went back to Sacrementoand pulled the bill
and we were actuallyquite ecstatic about that,
all of us, because we builta relationship that was,
it was built on some trust on both sides,
though we question each otherdeeply, there was a level
of trust that was being shaped and formed.
And that was what ACR 99 was born out of.
- So tell me, what is it about ACR 99
that you are in agreementabout with Evan Low?
- Well the things that we,after months and months
of meeting with the LGBTQCaucus in Sacremento,
having discussions withEvan, sitting with several
other pastors and writing resolutions
that were, from a Christian perspective,
we wrote I think sevendifferent resolutions
that we thought were gonna be passed.
Twice we thought we hada bill that was gonna,
a resolution that was gonna be presented
and right at the last minutethose resolutions got pulled
for numbers of different reasons.
Primarily because they were from
such a Christian perspective.
The thing that we agreedwith the LGBTQ Caucus on
was that we are not for anykind of coercive behavior
on the part of leadersor Counselors or pastors
and as we shared with the LGBTQ Caucus,
we don't know anybody inCalifornia that's Christian
that is actually doingwhat they're suggesting
that we're doing.
So we didn't--
- [Charlene] Is it therapyyou're talking about?
- Well, they call it conversion therapy,
but after sitting at the table with them
for extensive periods of discussions,
it's quite clear to usthat their interpretation
of conversion therapy in the gay community
and our interpretation inthe Christian community
are very, very different.
So what we see, what they see,
how we view conversiontherapy is very different.
So we actually opted notto use the term anymore
because we felt that itwasn't, it just wasn't clear
who was, when they arediscussing conversion therapy
and when we're discussing itis quite different discussion.
We're talking about two different things.
- Tell me, this Doctor Kevin Manno
of Azusa Pacific Universitysays that he expresses
various levels of supportfor this resolution
dealing with conversiontherapy and LGBTQ persons,
you know, and many callhis support for this
really he's saying he's apuppet for the gay community.
What's your response to that?
- Well my response firstoff, and as I shared
with Roger Ganoa when we spoke is that
without Kevin Manno's involvement in this
we would be fighting AB2943 in court right now.
We would be using ourresources to fight a bill
that would have gone throughthe court system for years.
And it was money that wecan use to care for the poor
to do ministry that we would have been
spending on that bill.
Kevin, because of hisrelationship, he also met
with Evan Low at the same time that I did
when Evan flew to Southern California.
He started a relationshipwith Evan as well
and so he and I can both havea relationship with Evan.
And Kevin's support of the bill is really
a support for the positions that say
we do not agree with coercive behavior,
we do not agree withwounding and hurting people,
we agreed with those partsof the, not the bill,
but the resolution, weagreed with those statements.
- But staying true toyour biblical convictions
about what the Bible saysabout human sexuality.
- None of us were agreeingwith the things that were in
the resolution and Iknow when Evan had Kevin
come to Sacremento and speakat the judiciary hearing
that Kevin was quite effusive about that.
I was actually invited to speak as well
and I wasn't in town at that time,
but Kevin's enthusiasm, if you would,
I think overstepped abit and so he's gotten
a lot of flack for that andtaken a lot of abuse for it.
But really the truthis is that Kevin holds
to Biblical perspective and his heart
is to try to build a relationshipwith the gay community
so we can talk.
It's the same perspective that I have.
- And Pastor Carroll, real quickly,
many say that Azusa Pacific University,
a Christian university hascaved to the LGBTQ crowd.
Do you agree with that assessment?
- No, I don't think that they've caved
into the LGBTQ crowd.
I think that the LGBTQ plus community
is wanting to have discussionswith our universities,
our Christian universities in California.
Is there a high levelof concern for pastors
like myself and other people, yes.
We talk about those things, I've spoken to
the people at Azusa Pacific about that.
We speak to the presidentsand the administrators
at the universities aroundus because we're concerned
that there is movementtowards a compromise.
We're concerned about that.
And when we talk to them,we are often reassured
that that is not actually taking place,
but that they have gaystudents on their campus
they're trying to sort outhow to manage that today.
I think that's the case at Azusa Pacifica.
I think they're tryingto sort out what to do
with the gay students that are coming
onto their campus todaybecause it is happening.
- Finally, what do you hope to see happen
from now moving forward?
- Well, what we try to,Charlene, is we try to create
relationship with the gay community.
In our estimation, it'sa bit of a runaway train
in Sacremento.
They were passing bills,they're passing laws.
We have no input at all,we have no discussion,
we have no say.
As Evan Low has said to us publicly,
they are super majority,they don't need us.
The fact that Evan is willing to come
and sit at the table withus is, in our estimation,
much better than just hurling
volatile bombs at each other across this
big, huge chasm that we have.
We have a canyon that separates us
and we talk about that openly
that our world views arevery, very different.
But it's in my estimation, Charlene,
it's much better for us tosit at the table and talk
with the gay communitythan it is just to be angry
with each other andmisunderstand each other.
Jesus always took the timeto interact with people.
So one of the things wetry to do is be honoring,
thoughtful, and kind every time we're with
these folks from the gay community.
And to their credit, they've done
the exact same thing with us.
There's suspicion, there's questions about
the Christians, there's(mumbling) for them.
But we've built a relationship
that's life giving withthem right now, Charlene.
So we like the fact thatthey will call us up,
say would you fly up and sit with us
and talk about this bill we're gonna pass
or this thing that we'reworking on right now.
- All right, Pastor DanCarroll, thank you so much
for your time and for gettingup so early over there
in Australia, God bless you.
- Charlene, bless you.
Thank you for your concerns,
take care.- Take care.